Alliance America Logo Contact About Us Articles Home
A stethoscope resting ontop of a stack of twenty dollar bills

How Medicare out-of-pocket costs really compare

by Sharon O'Day | Contributor
Feb 21, 2021


As you move into your 60s, you start looking forward to the day when you can get on Medicare – and leave the high premiums and copays of health insurance behind. As you begin to research how Medicare works and your various alternatives, the focus is first on what services are available. You try to sort out the pros and cons.

Medicare is not easy to understand until you are actually enrolled and using it. But it’s not so simple to change if you didn't make the best choice, particularly if you’re thinking of switching to Original Medicare and its supplement insurance (or Medigap) policies.

What’s equally as important as having access to the services you will need for the rest of your life is whether or not you can afford them.

By your 60s, you have a good idea of whether retirement will be fully funded, just squeaking by or a possible struggle. And that will tell you how critical it is to understand and peg down the out-of-pocket costs of Medicare coverage.

We won’t be examining the merits of your Medicare choices here. Instead, we will be focused exclusively on the costs involved. The hardest part of deciding on your future health care coverage is guessing how much you will need over the next 25 or 30 years. And your health today is not a reliable indicator of what it will be when you are 80.

(One thing to keep in mind as you start calculating costs is that several programs are available from the state and federal governments to help low-income beneficiaries meet their payment obligations.)

Understanding your Medicare choices

Medicare consists of four “parts,” plus a private supplement.

  • Part A: Hospital insurance
  • Part B: Medical insurance
  • Part C: Medicare Advantage
  • Part D: Prescription drug coverage
  • Medicare Supplement Insurance (Medigap) Policy

Your first decision will be to choose between the federal government’s Original Medicare or private insurers’ Medicare Advantage.

Original Medicare is made up of Part A and Part B. In addition, you can choose to add a private Part D policy, plus an optional Medigap policy.

Medicare Advantage (also known as Part C) replaces Part A and Part B and typically bundles Part D at no extra charge.

Here’s what the decision-making structure looks like:

Step by step chart of deciding between original medicare or medicare advantage plan

Out-of-pocket costs for Medicare plans are a bit like a puzzle. To understand the costs, you'll want to understand the various elements first:

  • Premium: The cost you pay monthly to access the various parts of your insurance.
  • Deductible: The amount you pay out-of-pocket each year for health care goods and services before your plan starts paying out.
  • Copayment: The price you pay for a specific product or service, set as a fixed price like $25 for a doctor’s visit.
  • Coinsurance: Your share of the total cost of a product or service, set as a percentage like 20%.

Original Medicare (also called traditional Medicare)

The government sets the costs for Part A (hospital insurance) and Part B (medical insurance), standardized for everyone. To reduce out-of-pocket costs, most people choose to add a Part D prescription drug plan and a supplement insurance (or Medigap) policy.

  • Medigap (supplement insurance) – Let's look at Medigap first, as it can affect the costs of many other parts under Original Medicare. Medigap is an optional type of insurance offered by private insurers. You choose the type of plan and the insurer, pay the premium, and the insurer picks up some or all of the costs not covered by Parts A and B.

Medigap premiums vary significantly with your choice of plan and insurer and are affected by your age, gender, where you live and whether you use tobacco. As a rough indication, the most comprehensive plan costs $143 a month on average. The website lets you compare the costs and benefits of different Medigap plans in your ZIP Code.

  • Part A (hospital insurance) – Ninety-nine percent of people do not pay a Part A premium because they earned free access by working enough during their (or their spouse’s) career. But if you are hospitalized in 2022, you will pay a deductible of $1,556 toward the cost of the first 60 days of each hospitalization. If you stay longer, you will pay a copayment of $389 per day for days 61-90 of each hospitalization, plus $778 per day after day 90 (for up to 60 “lifetime reserve” days).

Medigap plans can play an important role here: They will pay your Part A deductible and cover 365 days of hospital costs after your benefits are used up.

  • Part B (medical insurance) – Everyone pays a monthly Part B premium of $170.10 in 2022, or more if you are a high earner. The annual deductible is $233, meaning you pay that out-of-pocket before the insurer starts to pay. Few doctors’ visits will require copayments, but you may have to pay for some outpatient hospital services.

The greatest downside with Part B is that it only picks up 80% of Medicare-approved costs. So you will have to pay the remaining 20%, plus any unapproved costs. And there is no out-of-pocket maximum.

Again, Medigap comes to the rescue. While it no longer pays the deductibles on any newly purchased policies, it does pay virtually all of Part B’s coinsurance of 20%.

  • Part D (prescription drug coverage) – Your 2022 premium for Part D is determined by what plan you choose, where you live and how much you earn. According to Kaiser Family Foundation reports, premiums can range from as low as $5.50 in Colorado and as high as $207.20 in South Carolina. And even within a state, say Florida, they can range from $7.70 to $174.30.

In 2022, the standard deductible is $480 per year. Your copayments depend on what plan you choose and the medications you take. (You can determine the cost of your existing medicines on each plan's “formulary,” or price list, by visiting the website. After you meet the $480 deductible, what you pay is complex, with different stages and rates, up to a maximum out-of-pocket of $7,050.

Medigap does not cover your Part D prescription drug costs in any way.

Specific pricing – As an example, a quick search of the Medicare website for a Sarasota, Florida, ZIP Code results in:

  • Drug plan premium range: $7.70 to $174.30.
  • Medigap policy premium range: 12 plans in Florida from $46 to $1,172.35 per month. Medigap’s most comprehensive coverage today is available in Plan G.
    • For a 65-year-old non-smoker woman, it costs $170 to $229 per month.
    • For a 65-year-old smoker man, it costs $181 to $302 per month.

Medicare Advantage (also called Medicare Part C)

Medicare Part C is best known as Medicare Advantage. To sign up for Part C, you first have to sign up for Parts A and B. Once you do that, the federal government pays your selected insurer to provide the services you would otherwise get as Original Medicare. However, most Medicare Advantage insurers bundle in Part D, so you have no need for a Medigap or Part D standalone plan.

The insurers set the costs for Medicare Advantage plans with no guidelines from the government. However, they are working in a competitive environment, so they are motivated to make premiums affordable.

What you pay is also affected by the type of plan you choose. The options might look familiar if you had a private health care plan before Medicare: Health Maintenance Organization (HMO), Preferred Provider Organization (PPO), Private Fee-For-Service (PFFS) or Medicare Medical Savings Account (MSA).

Now let's look at the cost of the different Medicare parts.

Part A (hospital insurance) – Again, 99% of people are not required to pay a Part A premium, and if you are hospitalized, your plan pays the $1,556 deductible.

Part B (medical insurance) – Almost everyone pays the standard Part B monthly premium of $170.10 in 2022 or higher, based on your income. It is often deducted from your Social Security check if you have already claimed your retirement benefits. If not, you will be billed directly. However, recently some plans have started to compete by absorbing some or all of the Part B premium.

Part C (Medicare Advantage)Monthly premiums of $0 are not uncommon, but they can also reach hundreds of dollars. (The tradeoff usually comes in the size of the deductible.) However, the national average in 2021 was $21. Low-premium plans tend to have high deductibles, and vice versa.

You can change Medicare Advantage plans easily during each year’s open enrollment period. So, it might make sense to opt for a low-premium, high-deductible plan in the early years of retirement when you are healthiest and change as your needs evolve.

Separately, you will pay copayments and coinsurance for most doctor’s visits and medical procedures, as long as the doctors and hospitals are within your plan’s network. (Outside the network, the cost is entirely yours.) But again, the amounts depend on the plan you select. In any case, in 2022, the out-of-pocket maximum is $7,550. (This does not include expenses for prescription drugs, which have a separate deductible and out-of-pocket maximum.)

Part D (integrated prescription drug coverage) – Most Medicare Advantage plans include Part D for free. If your plan does not offer prescription drug coverage, you can buy a standalone Part D policy. However, if you buy one and your Part C plan also covers it, you can lose your Medicare Advantage coverage.

The Part D annual deductible can run up to $480, but your insurer may choose to set it at less. You will pay copayments and coinsurance based on your selected plan and the prescription medications you take. After meeting the deductible, you begin a sequence of “periods” with different payment requirements until you reach the maximum of $7,050. After that, you pay a small fixed-fee residual through the end of that calendar year.

Specific pricing – Go to the website to see the prices and tradeoffs of the various Medicare Advantage policies available in your ZIP Code. You can even input the medications you take today to understand better how much a Medicare Advantage policy might cost you.

As an example, a quick search of the Medicare website for a Sarasota, Florida, ZIP Code results in:

  • 24 HMO plans with
    • premiums ranging from $0 to $22.40
    • annual deductibles of $0
    • drug deductibles of $0 to $480
    • in-network maximums of $2,900 to $7,550
  • 17 PPO plans with
    • premiums ranging from $0 to $114
    • annual deductibles of $0 to $1,300
    • drug deductibles of $0 to $395
    • in-network maximums of $1,700 to $7,550
  • 1 PFFS plan with
    • premium of $102
    • annual deductible of $0
    • drug deductible of $200
    • maximum (in and out of network) of $6,700
  • 2 MSA plans with
    • premiums of $0
    • annual deductibles of $5,000 to $8,000
    • (part from the plan, part from you; you pay for health services)
    • drug deductibles (does not cover)

Wrapping up and comparing out-of-pocket costs

a picture of a spilt over pill bottle and a calculator with the input of Medicare part b both sitting ontop a pile of cash

For Original Medicare, using national averages, the monthly fixed costs could be:

  • Part B: $170.10
  • Part D: $33.37
  • Medigap: $143.00
    • Total: $346.37

For Medicare Advantage, they could be:

  • Part B: $170.10
  • Part C: $21.00
    • Total: $191.10

However, these are only the fixed costs. They do not include the extra out-of-pocket expenses linked to each option.

Because of that, Medicare Advantage may not necessarily be the best option. That depends on the deductible you choose and the volume of copayments and coinsurance you might need based on your health requirements now and in the future.

While no one can give you a definite “best value” answer, by understanding the various costs you will face with Medicare, you will be able to make a more informed decision.

Alliance America can help

Alliance America is an insurance and financial services company dedicated to the art of personal financial planning. Our financial professionals can assist you in maximizing your retirement resources and achieving your future goals. We have access to an array of products and services, all focused on helping you enjoy the retirement lifestyle you want and deserve. You can request a no-cost, no-obligation consultation by calling (833) 219-6884 today.

People on different levels showing varying levels of significance

Part of being significant means that you make a difference in the lives of others, especially your family and loved ones. Our significance in the workplace and in business leads to financial rewards and a sense of accomplishment.

Voluteers cleaning up trash

Our need and desire to contribute helps others meet their own seven core needs -- financial, health, safety, love, significance, growth and contribution.

Small people standing on stacks of quarters

We insure our homes from fire, floods and other hazards and need to protect our loved ones from unexpected perils. Retirement assets and resources also require safe havens and a prudent plan that safeguards them from the unknown.

Seniors exercising in a group class

Our lifestyle revolves around our health, so turning an arbitrary age doesn’t mean we need to stop being physically active and financially productive.