Alliance America Logo Contact About Us Articles Home
Person looking confused at wooden tiles toppling over like dominoes

Social Security misconceptions can impact retirement income

by Alliance America
October 17, 2023


Retirement planning includes difficult decisions and intricate calculations that are aimed at ensuring a comfortable lifestyle when you are no longer employed. At the heart of this planning lies the Social Security program — a system intended to support retirees but often misunderstood in its complexities. It's no surprise, then, that several misconceptions have arisen over the years regarding the role and functioning of Social Security benefits. By having an accurate understanding of Social Security, you can make informed decisions that align with your retirement goals.

Was Social Security intended to replace my entire income?

different dollar bills with social security cards on top

Social Security, established as a government program in 1935, was designed to provide a safety net for retired workers. However, it’s important to dispel the misconception that Social Security was intended to replace your entire income during retirement.

While it does offer financial support, relying solely on Social Security benefits may not be sufficient to maintain the same standard of living you had during your working years. When considering retirement income planning, it is crucial to understand that Social Security benefits are based on your lifetime earnings and employment history.

The amount you receive will depend on factors such as the number of years you worked and your highest earning years. Typically, Social Security replaces around 40% of pre-retirement income for most individuals.

To put this into perspective, imagine a retiree who earned an average annual salary of $60,000 throughout their working career. Based on the formula used by the Social Security Administration (SSA), their estimated monthly benefit at full retirement age would be approximately $1,800.

While this provides some income supplementation during retirement, it falls short of replacing their entire pre-retirement income. Relying solely on Social Security without other sources of income or retirement savings could lead to financial strain and limit your lifestyle choices during retirement.

To achieve a comfortable retirement, experts recommend saving and creating additional streams of income through personal savings accounts, employer-sponsored plans like 401(k)s or IRAs and annuities. By diversifying assets and considering various forms of investment vehicles with potential growth over time, individuals can better ensure a more financially secure future.

While Social Security provides essential support for retired workers in the form of benefits based on prior earnings and employment history, it was not originally intended to replace one's entire pre-retirement income. Understanding this misconception is crucial in planning for retirement effectively and incorporating other sources of income into a comprehensive strategy that considers personal savings accounts and investments alongside Social Security benefits.

If I claim Social Security at age 62, will it decrease my benefits?

One of the most common misconceptions about Social Security is that claiming benefits at age 62 will decrease the overall amount received. However, this is not entirely accurate. While it's true that claiming benefits early can result in a reduced monthly payment, it does not necessarily mean a decrease in the total amount received over time.

The reduction in benefits when claiming at age 62 is primarily due to the fact that you are starting payments earlier and therefore receiving them over a longer period. The Social Security Administration uses actuarial tables to calculate these reductions based on average life expectancy.

wooden blocks with the image of cost going down

The logic behind this approach is to roughly equalize the total lifetime benefits for those who claim early and those who wait until their full retirement age or even delay their claim beyond that. It's important to note that claiming Social Security at age 62 may make sense for some individuals depending on their unique circumstances.

If you have health issues or anticipate a shorter lifespan, claiming early might be beneficial as it allows you to receive income when you need it most. Additionally, if you're struggling financially and don't have other sources of retirement income, starting Social Security early could provide much-needed support.

However, if you have substantial other sources of income and assets or plan on continuing employment during your early retirement years, it may be more advantageous to delay your Social Security claim. Delaying can result in increased monthly benefit amounts and potentially higher annual earnings subject to taxation thresholds.

While claiming Social Security benefits at age 62 may lead to a reduced monthly payment compared to waiting until full retirement age or beyond, it does not necessarily result in an overall decrease in the total amount received over one's lifetime. Understanding your personal financial situation and consulting with a professional familiar with retirement income planning can help guide your decision-making process regarding when to claim Social Security benefits.

Is it possible to owe taxes on Social Security income?

Another common misconception about Social Security is that the benefits received are completely tax-free. However, it is indeed possible to owe taxes on your Social Security income. The amount of tax you owe depends on your total income and filing status.

Many retirees are surprised to find out they owe taxes on their Social Security benefits, as they assumed their retirement income would not be subject to taxation. To determine if you have to pay taxes on your Social Security benefits, the first step is calculating your provisional income.

This includes not only your Social Security benefits but also other sources of income such as wages, pensions and dividends. If your provisional income exceeds certain thresholds, a portion of your Social Security benefits may be subject to federal income taxes.

The percentage of your Social Security benefits that may be taxed varies depending on the level of provisional income reached. For example, if you're filing as an individual and your provisional income falls between $25,000 and $34,000, up to 50% of your benefits could be taxable.

If your provisional income exceeds $34,000 as an individual filer or $44,000 for joint filers, then up to 85% of your benefits could be subject to taxation. It's important for individuals who expect their retirement income from various sources – including Social Security – to consider potential tax implications when planning for their financial future.

Consulting with a financial professional can help you navigate the complexities of retirement planning and determine strategies for minimizing potential tax obligations while maximizing available benefits. While many people assume that their Social Security benefits are entirely tax-free during retirement years, this is a misconception that should not go unaddressed in retirement planning discussions.

It's crucial for individuals nearing retirement age or already retired to understand that depending on their overall level of provisional income (including all sources), they may have a portion of their Social Security benefits subjected to federal taxation. Being aware of these tax implications and seeking professional guidance can help retirees make informed decisions about their retirement income planning, ensuring they have a comprehensive understanding of their financial situation.

Actually, you can change your mind once you start claiming Social Security

Many retirees approach the decision to claim Social Security with a mix of anticipation and anxiety. Given the complexities surrounding the program, misconceptions inevitably arise — one of the most enduring being that once you start claiming Social Security, you're locked into that decision for life.

a big arrow pointing right with smaller arrows inside point the opposite way

It's important to understand where this misconception comes from. Social Security, with its web of rules and regulations, can appear daunting. The idea that once you've "pulled the trigger" on benefits you're committed is an understandable misreading of the system, especially given the irreversible nature of many financial decisions. But, in the case of Social Security, this isn't entirely true.

The SSA provides avenues for beneficiaries to adjust their initial decisions, albeit with some conditions. Here are two primary ways you can rethink your decision:

  • Withdrawal of application. If you've claimed benefits and soon after realize it might have been premature, you're in luck. The SSA allows beneficiaries to withdraw their application for benefits once in their lifetime. To do this, you must submit Form SSA-521 within 12 months of initiating your benefits. There's a catch, however: You must repay all the benefits you've received. This includes not just what you've been paid, but any benefits dispensed to dependents based on your record or money withheld, say, for Medicare premiums. Once done, it's as though you never applied. You can then decide to claim benefits at a later date, which could result in a higher monthly payout.

  • Voluntary suspension. If you've reached your full retirement age (FRA) but are not yet 70 and regret not having delayed your benefits to accrue delayed retirement credits, you have an option. You can request the SSA to suspend your benefits. During this suspension, you'll earn those sought-after delayed retirement credits, which will boost your monthly benefit once you resume receiving them. It's crucial to note that if other people, like your spouse or children, receive benefits based on your record, their benefits may be affected during the suspension period.

While these avenues provide flexibility, they also come with tradeoffs. Repaying benefits might not be feasible for everyone, especially if they've been used to cover living expenses. Additionally, when you suspend benefits, you might need an alternative source of income during that period.


It is evident that there are several misconceptions surrounding Social Security that need to be addressed. The notion that Social Security was designed to replace an individual's entire income is simply not true.

It was intended to provide a safety net and supplement retirement income, but careful retirement planning should involve other sources of income such as pensions, savings and investments. Understanding the various factors that can impact benefits is crucial for making informed decisions.

Another important misconception is the belief that claiming Social Security at age 62 will automatically decrease one's benefits. While it is true that early claiming can result in reduced benefits compared to waiting until full retirement age, this reduction will only be permanent if an individual continues to work and earn more than the annual earnings limit set by the SSA.

Once an individual reaches their full retirement age, they can claim their benefits without any reduction regardless of their employment or earnings. Many people are unaware that they may owe taxes on their Social Security income.

The taxability of Social Security benefits depends on an individual's total combined income, which includes their adjusted gross income plus any tax-exempt interest and half of their Social Security benefits. If your total combined income exceeds certain thresholds specified by the IRS, you may have to pay taxes on a portion of your Social Security benefits.

This highlights the importance of considering tax implications when planning for retirement and utilizing strategies to minimize taxable income. Debunking misconceptions about Social Security is essential for effective retirement planning.

Recognizing that it serves as a supplemental source of income rather than a replacement for an entire salary allows individuals to develop comprehensive strategies using various assets and sources of revenue. Understanding how claiming age impacts benefit amounts empowers individuals to make informed decisions based on their personal circumstances.

Being aware of potential taxes on Social Security allows retirees to accurately forecast post-retirement finances by incorporating these considerations into their overall financial plan.

Also, it’s reassuring to know that if you rethink your Social Security claiming decision, the system offers ways to adjust course. However, it's always advisable to consult with a financial professional before making or changing your decision.

By dispelling misunderstandings and embracing accurate information, individuals can optimize their Social Security benefits and pave the way for a more prosperous retirement.

Alliance America can help

Alliance America is an insurance and financial services company dedicated to the art of personal financial planning. Our financial professionals can assist you in maximizing your retirement resources and achieving your future goals. We have access to an array of products and services, all focused on helping you enjoy the retirement lifestyle you want and deserve. You can request a no-cost, no-obligation consultation by calling (833) 219-6884 today.

A mother reading a book with her daughter

Your legacy is vastly more than an amount of money left to your surviving beneficiaries. Part your legacy can be the example of a life well-lived that’s achieved through proper planning.

A senior couple stressed over tax liabilities

Too many people enter retirement with burdensome mortgages, car payments and credit-card debt that they’ve amassed during their working years. Proper management of these liabilities is fundamental to your current and future financial viability.

A daughter hugging her mother

Financial planning often is motivated by our love for our life partners, children, family members and friends.

Using a calculator to calculate taxes

Taxes have a significant impact your finances and can siphon assets unless you have a prudent approach to meet your objectives.