Alliance America Logo Contact About Us Articles Home
A black-and-white illustration of an older woman using a computer in a library with vast shelves of books, depicted with a question mark in a speech bubble above her head.

Decline of people-based customer service creates a digital divide for older consumers

by Alliance America
June 05, 2024


In the rapidly evolving world of commerce and customer relations, a seismic shift has occurred in how businesses provide service to their customers. Gone are the days when customer service was predominantly a realm of direct, in-person interactions, where a smile and a handshake were as much a part of the experience as the service itself. In recent years, a significant transformation has occurred, steering customer service away from these traditional methods and toward digital platforms. This shift, largely driven by the pursuit of greater efficiency and increased profit margins, has led to the widespread adoption of technologies such as mobile applications, QR codes and automated systems.

The implications of this digital revolution in customer service are far-reaching and multifaceted. On one hand, these technological advancements have introduced new levels of convenience and speed, changing the customer service landscape into a more efficient and streamlined process. For many, especially the tech-savvy and the digitally literate, this shift has been a welcome change. However, it's crucial to recognize that these advancements have not been universally beneficial. A significant segment of the population, particularly older consumers, finds itself grappling with these rapid changes. For them, the move away from traditional customer service to digital platforms represents not just a challenge but a fundamental barrier.

As a group that may not be as comfortable or familiar with digital technology as younger generations, older consumers often find themselves at a distinct disadvantage in this new era. The shift to digital platforms can present obstacles ranging from basic usability issues and a steep learning curve to more profound feelings of disconnection and alienation. This transition raises important questions about accessibility, inclusivity and the potential loss of the personal touch that has long been a hallmark of quality customer service.

Why has traditional customer service changed?

The transformation of customer service from traditional, face-to-face engagements to digital mediums signifies a pivotal change in the landscape of consumer interactions. This evolution has been driven by a confluence of factors, fundamentally altering the way businesses and customers interact. Those factors include:

  • Cost savings for businesses. One of the primary drivers of this shift has been the significant cost savings for businesses. Digital platforms allow companies to serve more customers with fewer personnel, reducing the overhead costs associated with staffing, training and maintaining physical customer service locations. Automated systems and digital tools have enabled businesses to streamline their operations, leading to increased efficiency and reduced expenses.
  • Perceived efficiency of digital interactions. The transition to digital mediums is also propelled by the perceived efficiency these platforms offer. Digital customer service tools, like chatbots and automated help centers, provide instant responses and solutions, which is often more time-efficient compared to traditional methods. Customers can access services and support at their convenience, without the limitations of business hours or the need for physical travel.
  • The burgeoning digital marketplace. The growth of the digital marketplace has played a crucial role in this shift. As more consumers move online for their shopping and service needs, businesses have adapted by enhancing their digital presence. This includes developing comprehensive websites, mobile applications and social media platforms that offer customer service capabilities. The ease of access and the wide reach of digital platforms have made them an attractive option for both businesses and consumers.
  • Rise of technology. The advent of advanced technologies like mobile apps, online portals and self-service kiosks has revolutionized customer service. Mobile apps provide a direct line of communication between businesses and consumers, offering features like in-app purchases, live chat support and personalized recommendations. Online portals serve as one-stop shops for customers, where they can access a range of services, from account management to support requests. Self-service kiosks in physical locations like stores and banks allow customers to perform a variety of tasks independently, without the need for human assistance.
  • A shift away from human elements. This move toward digital customer service represents a significant departure from the human elements that traditionally defined customer interactions. Personalized service, empathetic listening and direct human engagement have been hallmarks of traditional customer service. The digital model, while efficient and accessible, often lacks these personal touches. The experience can feel impersonal and detached, as the nuances of human communication are hard to replicate in digital formats.

The shift to digital customer service is characterized by its focus on efficiency, cost-effectiveness and adaptability to the growing digital marketplace. However, this transformation also signifies a move away from the human-centered approach of traditional customer service, raising questions about the implications of such a change, especially for demographics less accustomed to or comfortable with digital technology.

What are the customer-service challenges for older consumers?

A person using a self-service checkout screen in a grocery store, with a bag of oranges on the scale and payment terminals nearby.

The rapid digitalization of customer service, while beneficial for many, poses significant challenges for older consumers. This demographic, which often does not share the same level of comfort or familiarity with digital technology as younger generations, faces unique customer-service challenges that include:

  • A lack of digital literacy. A major hurdle for many older consumers is a lack of digital literacy. Unlike younger generations who grew up with technology, many seniors did not have the same exposure to digital devices and online platforms. This gap in digital skills can make it difficult for them to navigate apps, websites and other digital customer service tools. Simple tasks like navigating a menu, filling out online forms or even understanding icons and digital cues can be challenging, leading to frustration and a sense of helplessness.
  • Navigating new technologies. For older consumers, keeping up with rapidly evolving technologies can be overwhelming. The constant updates, new software and changes in interfaces can be confusing and may require relearning processes they had just begun to understand. This ongoing need to adapt can be taxing both mentally and physically, especially for those who may also be dealing with age-related cognitive or motor skill decline.
  • A preference for human interaction. Many older consumers have a natural preference for human interaction when it comes to customer service. They value the personal touch, empathy and immediacy that come from dealing with another person, which is often missing in digital interactions. The shift to digital platforms removes this element, making the customer service experience feel impersonal and disconnected.
  • Emotional implications. The move away from traditional customer service models can have emotional implications for older consumers. Struggling with digital platforms can lead to feelings of isolation, especially if these platforms are seen as the only means of accessing services or support. Additionally, the inability to interact with a human representative can exacerbate feelings of loneliness, a significant issue among the older population.
  • Practical barriers to accessing services. The digitalization of customer service can create practical barriers for older consumers in accessing essential services. Whether it's managing their finances, seeking medical advice or making everyday purchases, the reliance on digital platforms can be a significant hindrance. This barrier can lead to a decreased ability to manage personal affairs independently, potentially impacting their quality of life and overall well-being.

There's no doubt that the shift to digital customer service can present a range of challenges for older consumers, from the struggle to develop digital literacy to the emotional and practical implications of this change. These challenges highlight the need for more inclusive customer service strategies that consider the diverse capabilities and preferences of all consumer groups, especially the elderly.

What industries and services are most affected?

Elderly man with a beard, looking stressed while holding a credit card and examining a laptop screen, in a well-lit room.

The shift away from traditional, human-centric customer service to digital platforms has had a significant impact across various industries. However, this transition has been particularly noticeable in certain key sectors such as banking, retail and health care. These industries, integral to daily life, have undergone digital transformations that, while offering benefits like increased efficiency and accessibility for some, have inadvertently created barriers for older consumers.

In the banking sector, the move toward online and mobile banking has been rapid. While digital banking offers convenience with features like online account management, electronic bill payments and mobile check deposits, it has also reduced the availability and necessity of in-person banking services. For many older adults, who may prefer face-to-face interactions for complex transactions or simply lack the confidence in navigating online banking platforms, this shift can lead to difficulties in managing their finances . Moreover, the closure of physical bank branches in favor of digital services has further limited their options.

The retail industry has also seen a significant move toward digital platforms. Online shopping, self-checkout kiosks and digital payment systems are becoming increasingly common. While these advancements streamline the shopping experience for many, they can be challenging for older consumers who are not accustomed to such technology. The lack of assistance in navigating digital payment systems or online shopping portals can make everyday purchases a daunting task. Additionally, the reduced number of staff available for in-person assistance in stores can leave older shoppers feeling unsupported and isolated.

Perhaps one of the most critical areas impacted by the digital shift is the health care industry. Telemedicine, online appointment scheduling and electronic health records have become more prevalent. These digital services can provide significant benefits in terms of accessibility and efficiency; however, for older patients, they may pose challenges. Difficulties in using telemedicine platforms, confusion over accessing electronic health records or the inability to schedule appointments online can impede their access to health care. Furthermore, the personal interaction with health care providers, which can be crucial for older patients, is often diminished in these digital exchanges.

Beyond these industries, the digitalization of customer service affects a wide range of everyday transactions and services, from using public transportation to interacting with government agencies. The assumption that all consumers are digitally literate excludes a significant portion of the older population, leading to a gap in service accessibility.

The digital divide and accessibility issues

An elderly male shopkeeper in a green apron smiles while looking at a tablet inside a grocery store, with shelves of products in the background.

The digital divide, a term that has gained increasing relevance in today's technology-driven society, is particularly poignant when considering the challenges faced by older adults. This divide is more than just a gap. It's a chasm that separates those who are proficient in digital technology from those who are not. This disparity is starkly evident in the older generation, many of whom did not grow up in the digital age and, as a result, find themselves at a significant disadvantage in a world increasingly dominated by digital interactions.

Older adults, many of whom may have had limited exposure to computers and the internet during their working lives, often find themselves struggling to keep pace with the rapid advancements in technology. While younger generations navigate these digital landscapes almost intuitively, older individuals may grapple with even the basic functionalities of modern digital devices and platforms. This gap in digital proficiency can lead to a sense of alienation and frustration, further widening the divide.

One of the most pressing issues arising from the digital divide is the lack of accessibility in digital customer service platforms. Many of these platforms are designed with the assumption that users have a certain level of digital literacy and physical ability to interact with them. This design philosophy can result in interfaces that are not user-friendly for older adults, who may have limitations in vision, hearing or motor skills, making navigation and comprehension challenging. For instance, small text sizes, complex menus and the need for precise touchscreen interactions can be significant barriers.

Another critical aspect of the digital divide is the diminishing availability of alternative, non-digital means of accessing services. As businesses and services increasingly push their customers toward online platforms, the availability of traditional methods, such as telephone-based customer service or in-person assistance, has decreased. This shift effectively marginalizes those who are either unable or unwilling to engage with digital platforms, leaving them with few alternatives to access essential services.

The digital divide also highlights the need for targeted digital education and support for older adults. While there are initiatives aimed at improving digital literacy among seniors, these are often not widespread or well-publicized. Moreover, the training needs to be tailored to address the specific challenges and learning styles of older individuals, ensuring that it is both effective and empowering.

Addressing the accessibility issues in digital platforms requires a shift toward more inclusive design practices. This means creating interfaces and experiences that are easily navigable and understandable by people of all ages and abilities. It involves considering factors like clear and larger text, simple navigation menus, voice-assisted technology and the provision of clear, step-by-step instructions.

The importance of the human touch

As the world continues its relentless march toward digitalization, the enduring importance of human interaction in customer service becomes ever more evident, particularly for older consumers. The shift toward digital mediums, while offering efficiency and convenience, often lacks the personal touch and empathy inherent in human interactions, elements that are especially valued by the older generation.

The psychological benefits of human interaction in customer service are profound, especially for older adults who may be more prone to feelings of isolation or loneliness. Personalized service, characterized by direct communication, empathy and understanding, can significantly enhance their experience. It provides a sense of connection and belonging, something that automated digital systems struggle to replicate. This human element can transform a routine service interaction into an opportunity for meaningful connection, offering reassurance and a sense of being valued and heard.

From a practical standpoint, speaking directly to a human representative can significantly simplify the process of seeking assistance or resolving issues. Older consumers often find it easier to explain their needs or problems verbally rather than navigating through a series of digital menus and options. Human representatives can also offer immediate clarification and guidance, adapting their responses to the specific context of the inquiry, which automated systems may not be able to do.

The presence of human interaction in customer service plays a crucial role in building customer satisfaction and loyalty. Older customers, in particular, are more likely to remain loyal to a service or brand that provides personalized, empathetic interactions. This loyalty is not merely a reflection of their satisfaction with the product or service itself but also their appreciation for being treated with respect and understanding.

For complex or sensitive issues, the human touch becomes even more critical. Older adults may have specific needs or concerns that require a nuanced and compassionate approach, something that automated systems are not equipped to handle. A human representative can offer tailored advice, provide emotional support and ensure that the customer's needs are adequately addressed.

To maximize the benefits of human interaction in customer service, there is a need for focused training and skills development for customer service representatives. This training should emphasize not only the technical aspects of the products and services but also the development of soft skills such as empathy, patience and effective communication. Equipping representatives with these skills ensures that they can provide the high level of service that older customers appreciate.

Alliance America can help

Alliance America is an insurance and financial services company dedicated to the art of personal financial planning. Our financial professionals can assist you in maximizing your retirement resources and achieving your future goals. We have access to an array of products and services, all focused on helping you enjoy the retirement lifestyle you want and deserve. You can request a no-cost, no-obligation consultation by calling (833) 219-6884 today.

A mother reading a book with her daughter

Your legacy is vastly more than an amount of money left to your surviving beneficiaries. Part your legacy can be the example of a life well-lived that’s achieved through proper planning.

A senior couple stressed over tax liabilities

Too many people enter retirement with burdensome mortgages, car payments and credit-card debt that they’ve amassed during their working years. Proper management of these liabilities is fundamental to your current and future financial viability.

A daughter hugging her mother

Financial planning often is motivated by our love for our life partners, children, family members and friends.

Using a calculator to calculate taxes

Taxes have a significant impact your finances and can siphon assets unless you have a prudent approach to meet your objectives.