Alliance America Logo Contact About Us Articles Home
a key and two locks

Decoding Medicare vs. Medicare Advantage: unveiling key differences

by Alliance America
December 29, 2023


When it comes to health care coverage for American citizens, Medicare stands as a stalwart program providing essential benefits to those ages 65 and older, as well as certain individuals with disabilities.

Established in 1965, Medicare offers a range of services encompassing hospital insurance (Part A), medical insurance (Part B) and prescription drug coverage (Part D). Traditional Medicare operates through the federal government and remains the predominant choice for many older Americans seeking comprehensive health care coverage.

However, an alternative option gaining popularity is Medicare Advantage. Medicare Advantage plans, also known as Part C plans or MA plans, are an alternative way to receive Medicare benefits. The enrollment in Medicare Advantage plans has seen a significant rise, with half (51%) of all eligible Medicare beneficiaries enrolled in them in 2023. That number has increased from 19% of the eligible Medicare population that was enrolled in Medicare Advantage plans in 2007.

These plans are offered by private insurance companies that have been approved by the federal government. In contrast to traditional fee-for-service Medicare, which allows individuals to visit any health care provider that accepts Medicare patients, Medicare Advantage plans operate on a managed care model.

magnifying glass looking a Medicare options

This means that individuals must select health care providers within the plan's network or pay higher out-of-pocket costs for services received outside of the network. One of the primary advantages of traditional Medicare is its flexibility in terms of choosing doctors and hospitals without restrictions imposed by network limitations.

Enrollees can select from any physician or hospital that accepts traditional fee-for-service Medicare patients, giving them a wide range of choices for their health care needs. Moreover, with traditional Medicare, there is no requirement for referrals from primary care physicians before seeing specialists.

This freedom allows patients greater autonomy in managing their health and seeking specialized care when necessary. On the other hand, while traditional fee-for-service Medicare provides broad access to health care providers across the country, it does not typically cover all medical expenses.

This freedom allows patients greater autonomy in managing their health and seeking specialized care when necessary. On the other hand, while traditional fee-for-service Medicare provides broad access to health care providers across the country, it does not typically cover all medical expenses.

Medicare Advantage plans, in contrast, often provide coverage for additional services not covered by traditional Medicare, such as vision care, dental care and hearing aids. These plans may also offer a more structured approach to health care management through coordinated care systems.

Under Medicare Advantage plans, individuals are encouraged to choose a primary care physician who will oversee their health care needs and coordinate referrals to specialists when necessary. This approach aims to streamline care coordination and potentially improve health outcomes for beneficiaries.

While Medicare serves as a comprehensive federal program that provides health care coverage for millions of Americans age 65 and older or with certain disabilities, it is important to consider the pros and cons of traditional fee-for-service Medicare versus the alternative option of Medicare Advantage plans. Traditional Medicare offers greater flexibility in provider choice but comes with potential gaps in coverage that may require additional insurance.

Conversely, Medicare Advantage plans offer additional benefits and coordinated care but come with limitations on provider choices. Evaluating individual health care needs and preferences is crucial in determining which option best suits each person's unique circumstances.

Understanding traditional Medicare and Parts A, B and D

Traditional Medicare is a federal health insurance program in the United States that provides coverage for individuals who are 65 years or older, as well as certain younger individuals with disabilities.

It consists of three main parts: Part A, Part B and Part D. Each part plays a crucial role in providing comprehensive coverage to beneficiaries. Part A of Medicare primarily covers hospital stays, skilled nursing facility care, hospice care and some home health services.

This portion of Medicare is often referred to as "hospital insurance." Beneficiaries do not typically pay a premium for Part A if they or their spouse have paid Medicare taxes while working. However, there are deductibles and coinsurance associated with specific services.

Part B of Medicare covers medical services like doctor visits, outpatient care, preventive services and durable medical equipment. This portion is often referred to as "medical insurance." Unlike Part A, beneficiaries must pay a monthly premium for Part B coverage.

The premium amount may vary based on the beneficiary's income level. Additionally, there is an annual deductible that must be met before Medicare starts paying its share of covered services.

Part D of Medicare offers prescription drug coverage to beneficiaries. It helps cover the cost of prescription medications at participating pharmacies or through mail-order programs approved by Medicare.

These plans are provided by private insurance companies approved by the government. Beneficiaries can choose between standalone prescription drug plans (PDPs) or opt for a Medicare Advantage plan that includes prescription drug coverage (MA-PDs).

Each plan has its own list of covered drugs (formulary), which may vary in terms of cost-sharing requirements. Understanding the nuances and provisions within each part of traditional Medicare is essential for beneficiaries when gauging their health care needs and financial obligations effectively.

By comprehending how Parts A, B, and D work together cohesively under this federal program's umbrella framework, individuals can make informed decisions about their health care coverage and explore potential alternatives, such as Medicare Advantage plans. It is imperative to carefully evaluate the costs, benefits, and restrictions associated with each part of traditional Medicare to ensure optimal usage of the available resources and maximize the quality of care received.

Pros and cons of traditional Medicare

tablet with Medicare on the screen

While traditional Medicare offers comprehensive benefits, there are both advantages and disadvantages to consider when evaluating this program.

One significant advantage of traditional Medicare is its widespread acceptance by health care providers across the country. With a vast network of doctors, specialists, hospitals and other medical facilities that participate in the program, beneficiaries have access to a wide range of health care services.

This means that individuals can choose their preferred health care providers without concerns about whether or not they accept Medicare. Moreover, with traditional Medicare's extensive coverage options under Part A (hospital insurance), including inpatient care and skilled nursing facilities, beneficiaries have peace of mind knowing that major medical expenses will be covered.

Another advantage is the flexibility offered by traditional Medicare's fee-for-service structure. Unlike Medicare Advantage plans, which typically involve restricted networks or require referrals to see specialists, traditional Medicare allows beneficiaries to visit any doctor or specialist without needing a referral.

This freedom allows individuals to seek specialized care from top experts or access specific medical facilities that may not be part of an Advantage plan's network. Furthermore, as there are no prior authorization requirements under traditional Medicare for most services rendered by providers who accept the program's payment terms, beneficiaries have more control over their health care decisions.

Despite these advantages, there are also some notable drawbacks associated with traditional Medicare. One significant concern is its lack of out-of-pocket cost protection.

While Part A generally does not require premiums if an individual has paid enough into Social Security during their working years effectively making it "earned" insurance, both Part B (medical insurance) and Part D (prescription drug coverage) involve monthly premiums based on income levels. Additionally, traditional Medicare typically has deductibles and co-insurance responsibilities that could lead to substantial out-of-pocket costs for beneficiaries unless supplemented by additional coverage like Medigap policies or Medicaid.

Moreover, traditional Medicare does not cover certain services such as dental, vision and hearing care. This can be particularly burdensome for older adults who may require these types of services more frequently.

Individuals relying solely on traditional Medicare would need to seek alternative coverage options or pay for these services out-of-pocket. Furthermore, the lack of prescription drug coverage under Part A and limited coverage under Part B can pose challenges for beneficiaries who require routine medications or specialized treatments.

Considering these pros and cons is essential when evaluating whether traditional Medicare is the right choice for an individual's health care needs. While it offers broad access to health care providers and allows greater flexibility in choosing specialists, the potential out-of-pocket costs and limited coverage may prompt some individuals to explore other options such as Medicare Advantage plans.

Understanding Medicare Advantage plans

Medicare Advantage plans often offer additional benefits that can make them an appealing choice for many beneficiaries. One of the key features of Medicare Advantage plans is that they typically include prescription drug coverage, which is not included in traditional Medicare.

This means beneficiaries do not have to enroll in a separate prescription drug plan (Part D) if they choose a Medicare Advantage Plan. The inclusion of drug coverage can be particularly advantageous for individuals who require regular medications and want the convenience of having all their medical needs covered under one plan.

Another important aspect of Medicare Advantage plans is that many of them offer additional benefits beyond what traditional Medicare provides. These extra benefits may include vision care, dental services, hearing aids, fitness programs and even transportation services.

Another important aspect of Medicare Advantage plans is that many of them offer additional benefits beyond what traditional Medicare provides. These extra benefits may include vision care, dental services, hearing aids, fitness programs and even transportation services.

HMO plans generally require beneficiaries to seek care within a specific network of health care providers and obtain referrals from their primary care physician for specialist visits. On the other hand, PPO plans allow beneficiaries more flexibility in choosing health care providers but often at a higher cost.

By providing access to additional benefits such as prescription drug coverage and optional extras like dental or vision services, these plans can greatly enhance individuals' overall health care experience beyond what traditional Medicare provides. Considering the specific needs and preferences of each beneficiary is essential in determining whether a Medicare Advantage plan is the right choice for them.


The decision between Medicare and Medicare Advantage ultimately depends on the individual's specific needs and preferences. Traditional Medicare offers a wide range of coverage options, allowing beneficiaries to choose their healthcare providers and specialists freely.

Additionally, it provides access to a comprehensive list of medications through separate Part D plans. However, it comes with higher out-of-pocket costs and requires additional supplemental insurance to cover deductibles and coinsurance.

On the other hand, Medicare Advantage plans offer convenience by bundling all benefits into one package. These plans often include additional services like vision, dental and hearing coverage that are not covered by traditional Medicare.

They also provide protection against catastrophic health care costs through out-of-pocket maximums. Additionally, many Medicare Advantage plans offer prescription drug coverage as part of their package.

While both options have their advantages and disadvantages, it is crucial for individuals to carefully evaluate their health care needs and budget constraints before making a decision. Considering factors such as preferred doctors or specialists, anticipated medication requirements, geographic location and financial considerations will help determine which program is the best fit.

Alliance America can help

Alliance America is an insurance and financial services company dedicated to the art of personal financial planning. Our financial professionals can assist you in maximizing your retirement resources and achieving your future goals. We have access to an array of products and services, all focused on helping you enjoy the retirement lifestyle you want and deserve. You can request a no-cost, no-obligation consultation by calling (833) 219-6884 today.

A mother reading a book with her daughter

Your legacy is vastly more than an amount of money left to your surviving beneficiaries. Part your legacy can be the example of a life well-lived that’s achieved through proper planning.

A senior couple stressed over tax liabilities

Too many people enter retirement with burdensome mortgages, car payments and credit-card debt that they’ve amassed during their working years. Proper management of these liabilities is fundamental to your current and future financial viability.

A daughter hugging her mother

Financial planning often is motivated by our love for our life partners, children, family members and friends.

Using a calculator to calculate taxes

Taxes have a significant impact your finances and can siphon assets unless you have a prudent approach to meet your objectives.